Comparing options to replace traditional cable TV
Quick Summary: For the closest experience to traditional cable with all major networks, local news, and major events like the Super Bowl, Olympics, and awards shows, YouTube TV or Hulu + Live TV are the best options.
$82.99/month
Best For: Anyone wanting a traditional TV experience with all the channels they're used to. This is the closest replacement for cable TV.
$89.99/month
Note: Interface can feel busier mixing live TV and on-demand content
Best For: Anyone who also wants streaming content (shows, movies) alongside live TV. You essentially get 4 services in 1.
$60.99/month
Orange + Blue combo plan
Not Recommended For: Traditional TV viewers. The missing networks mean you'll miss too many major events and local news. Only good if you know exactly which channels you need and CBS isn't one of them.
$33/month
Why It Won't Work:
Entertainment/lifestyle channels only. Not a cable replacement.
NBC has exclusive U.S. broadcast rights for the Olympics through 2032. Here's how each service handles Olympic coverage:
💡 Pro Tip: For the most complete Olympic experience, some people also add Peacock Premium ($7.99/month) alongside their live TV service.
Peacock (NBC's streaming service) sometimes has exclusive Olympic streams, replays, and extended coverage. But the main primetime events will always be on NBC's broadcast network, which both YouTube TV and Hulu + Live TV provide.
If you're considering sharing a subscription between two households (like Ossining and Peekskill), here's what you need to know:
Can work with effort:
More difficult:
Easiest to share:
Honest Assessment: While sharing is technically possible with YouTube TV (with quarterly visits), getting a separate subscription gives complete independence and avoids workarounds. The cost difference ($82.99 solo vs. ~$41.50 each if splitting) may be worth the convenience and peace of mind.
Get YouTube TV ($82.99/month) for the cleanest, most cable-like experience with all channels and no workarounds needed.
Get Hulu + Live TV ($89.99/month) if you also want Disney+, ESPN+, and thousands of on-demand shows/movies included.
YouTube TV can work with quarterly check-ins (visiting each other every ~3 months to connect to WiFi). Split cost would be ~$41.50 each.
💡 Pro tip: All these services offer free trials. Try YouTube TV for 7 days before committing to see if it feels right!
Pricing and features current as of February 2026